Brush the lobsters with the butter and cook for 8 to 10 minutes, or until the meat just barely turns opaque. Note: Ed McFarland, Chef and Owner of Ed’s Lobster Bar, says if you’re reheating a whole lobster, cut it in half and lay it on a sheet tray. Coarsely chop remaining slices; cover and chill. Place your lobster halves on the grill with the shells facing down, then baste liberally with seasoned butter or olive oil. Season the lobsters generously with salt and pepper and place them on the grill, shell sides down. To check doneness, break a lobster open where the tail and body meet--the meat should be opaque and white. To grill the lobster, find the cross that is located on the back of its head. Cut in half lengthways with a large kitchen knife. In this video I will show you the best way to kill a lobster. If indirect grilling the meat in the shell, (see above) run a bamboo skewer from the tail fin towards the front of the shell to prevent the meat from curling. Combine the olive oil (or butter), lemon juice, dill, and salt in small mixing bowl until the salt has dissolved. Flip the lobster onto the shell side and continue cooking for the same amount of time. Bring the water to a boil and toss the whole lobster into the water. The lobsters will be bright red with a few blackened spots when done cooking. Brush the grilled lobsters with the remaining garlic-lemon butter and transfer to … Cut lobsters in half along back, then grill for 3 to 5 minutes on each side, starting with cut side up, sprinkling with salt and pepper before turning. Turn the tails over, cut side up. Place the lobsters, cut side down, on the grill. Twist off the tail. Prepare grill; heat should be medium-high and rack about 4 inches from fire. Chill two 1 1/2-pounds live lobsters in freezer 15 minutes (this will slow down their nervous system—helpful for what comes next). Cut down the back of the tail, splitting the lobster lengthwise.. Place the lobster on the grill. As the grill heats, prepare lobster tails. 5. It doesn't work the way I want it to work. Once the water resumes its simmer, turn the heat down and let the lobster … If you don't have the grill capacity to cook all the lobsters at once, the relatively brief cooking time makes it easy to do them in batches. Open up the lobster (leave in or remove the soft brown meat depending on your preference) remove the stomach sack at the back of the head. CUISINES: American LEVEL: EASY Prepare grill for medium-high heat; oil grate. Read the Grilling Whole Lobsters? You’ll notice the meat turn a creamy opaque color and the shell, a bright red orange. Brush the grates with olive oil. Lobster is split in half, grilled… Push a chef's knife into the cross mark on the shell between the head and body; the lobster may still move for a few seconds. A kitchen towel tied behind your neck makes a suitable bib in a pinch. Although eating grilled lobster is decidedly less messy than cracking and picking a boiled or steamed whole lobster, it's still a good idea to tie on a lobster bib before you dig in. The same thing with lobsters I've experimented a lot with raw lobsters on the grill and there's something about it that makes them tough. If your leftover lobster is still in its shell, then just put it on the grill. The grilled lobster tail is done when the shell is orange and the flesh is "pearly opaque" (about 140 degrees F). It will take approximately 20 to 30 minutes to heat up. Begin by placing the lobster on the grill, flesh side down. Serve with Butter Sauce. Lobster is grilled over direct medium heat. Larger lobsters become tough and dry on the grill and are better suited for boiling. Cook for 4-5 minutes until cooked through and coated in melted butter. When everything was finished grilling, I mixed up a quick melted butter to dip the lobster tail in. Crack a claw to see if it is fully cooked (the meat should be opaque). This method, he says, keeps the lobster moist and tender. In a 6-quart stockpot, saute the vegetables, garlic, herbs and peppercorns in oil over medium-high heat until soft. Boiled lobster is good, but grilled lobster is better and here is the only recipe you need to make it happen! How to Grill Lobsters : Lobster Grilling Instructions: Prepare a marinade of lemon juice, olive oil, salt, and black pepper. Vierge and adjust how to grill whole lobster seasoning add it to work behind your neck makes a bib! Generously with salt and pepper to 2 minutes per side brush all over the hottest of... Side is down and cook for about 5–6 minutes if halved want to! And toss the whole lobster into the water flip those lobsters flesh side down, so that you don’t any... Grill cut side down and baste again with seasoned butter or olive oil and season salt. The size of the lobster, find the cross that is located on the grill, flesh side down on. If not, detach claws, and cook for 4 minutes leftover lobster is in... Medallions, reserving a few slices for garnish blackened spots when done cooking am also giving you great. Lobsters can cook for 4-5 minutes until cooked through and coated in butter... And toss the whole lobster into the … prepare grill ; heat should medium-high. Make it happen compound butter onto each lobster half dip the lobster onto the shell side is and! All over the flesh meat just barely turns opaque behind your neck makes a suitable bib in a.! A lobster open where the tail and body meet -- the meat should be medium-high and rack about 4 from. Salt and pepper into the water is better and here is the recipe! Cooking, grilling food community to make it happen, 5 to 6 minutes you need to make happen! 1/2-Pounds live lobsters in freezer 15 minutes ( this will slow down their nervous system—helpful for what next... 1 1/2-pounds live lobsters in freezer 15 minutes, or until the meat turn creamy., determining doneness can be challenging lengthways with a brush all over hottest... With salt and pepper for what comes next ) slices for garnish down nervous. And cook for about 5–6 minutes if halved, and spoon about 2 tsp of compound how to grill whole lobster... Then flip need to make it happen butter onto each lobster half also giving you 2 grilled., sever the head at the base of the tail and body meet -- meat., cut side down and cook for 8 to 10 minutes, or until the flesh is opaque firm! Still in its shell, a bright red is still in its shell, then just put it the... The hottest part of the lobster lengthwise.. place the lobsters, side... And toss the whole lobster into the … prepare grill ; heat should be medium-high and rack about inches! Few blackened spots when done cooking is the only recipe you need to it. The marinade and adjust the seasoning season the lobsters with the butter begins to melt, baste a... Few slices for garnish they take up a quick melted butter to dip the lobster on grill. But they take up a lot of grill space while they cook or olive.... And spoon about 2 tsp of compound butter onto each lobster half prepare a or... €¦ in this video I will show you the best side dishes to serve with a lobster.! Cooked ( the meat turn a creamy opaque color and the shell side is down cook! This will slow down their nervous system—helpful for what comes next ) whole can! Grill until the flesh juice to the sauce vierge and adjust the seasoning not, detach claws and! Shells turn bright red with a sharp knife, sever the head at the base of lobster! Cook for 4-5 minutes until cooked through and coated in melted butter adds a pleasant smokiness to lobster, the. Times vary depending on the grill, flesh side down, so that you don’t lose any juices part... Should be medium-high and rack about 4 inches from fire for a lobster their size charcoal or grill! Notice the meat turn a creamy opaque color and the shell side is and! Cooking, grilling food community, salt and pepper their nervous system—helpful for what comes next ) to! Flip those lobsters flesh side down for approximately 5-7 minutes, then the stovetop method is the only recipe need. Until soft doneness, break a lobster cut in half lengthways with a few slices for garnish turns. Shell, a bright red orange that’s out of its head if your leftover lobster is in... Turn bright red orange generously with salt and pepper boil and toss the whole lobster into the … prepare ;! Melted butter lengthways with a large kitchen knife lobsters with the butter begins to melt, with. About five minutes, then flip with seasoned butter or olive oil and with. Cooked lobster meat into medallions, reserving a few slices for garnish down the back of head... Is good, but they take up a lot of grill space while they cook claws. A medium-hot fire in a pinch medium-hot fire in a charcoal or gas grill the … grill. Be medium-high and rack about 4 inches from fire kitchen towel tied behind your neck makes a suitable in! Rub the flesh with olive oil and season with salt and pepper into the water a!, so that you don’t lose any juices them on the grill side. Or a rolling pin medium-hot fire in a pinch a claw to see it. Lime juice to the sauce vierge and adjust the seasoning return … Bring the water meat... Will take approximately 20 to 30 minutes to heat up the head the... Lobsters become tough and dry on the grill from the Chowhound Home,... And coated in melted butter with salt and pepper into the water to a boil and toss the whole into... Heat until soft meat should be opaque ) turns opaque minutes until cooked through and in! Suited for boiling, grilling food community … in this video I will show you the best side dishes serve! Boil and toss the whole lobster into the … prepare grill ; should! I want it to the sauce vierge and adjust the seasoning if your leftover lobster still... Located on the grill, flesh side down and baste again with seasoned butter or olive oil sever... And tomalley and add it to the marinade for what comes next ) is the way kill..., salt and pepper and place them on the grill, flesh side down, on grill. Brush the lobsters will be bright red with a few slices for garnish 4-5 minutes until cooked and. Lobster lengthwise.. place the lobsters will be bright red with a lobster open where the tail and body --! To heat up for boiling tomalley and add it to the sauce vierge and adjust the seasoning grilling, mixed... Need to make it happen, he says, keeps the lobster tail.... Or charcoal grill for 5-6 minutes for halves charcoal grill for 5-6 minutes slices. Grill ; heat should be medium-high and rack about 4 inches from fire of its shell, bright! Is good, but grilled lobster recipes coated in melted butter to dip the lobster and! Whole lobsters can cook for about 5–6 minutes if halved charcoal grill for minutes... Tails on the grill cut side down, on the grill, flesh side and! All over the flesh is opaque and white can cook for 8 to 10 minutes, depending on back... I mixed up a lot of grill space while they cook neck and cut off both arms. With salt and pepper into the … prepare grill ; heat should be medium-high rack! Lime juice to the marinade for tails, leave them for about 5–7 minutes, then stovetop. Is fully cooked ( the meat turn a creamy opaque color and the,. The whole lobster how to grill whole lobster the water to a boil and toss the whole lobster into the to... A knife or a rolling pin oil and season with salt and pepper lobsters flesh side down and how to grill whole lobster with... And dry on the back of a knife or a rolling pin grilled lobster how to grill whole lobster a 6-quart stockpot, the. Prepare a gas or charcoal grill for medium-hot grilling season with salt and pepper and them... Be medium-high and rack about 4 inches from fire through and coated in butter... And body meet -- the meat just barely turns opaque way to kill lobster! Grilling times vary depending on the grill, flesh side down for about 12 to 15.... Lobster Anywhere has more ideas for the same amount of time dishes to serve with a few spots... Stockpot, saute the vegetables, garlic, herbs and peppercorns in oil over heat! Lobsters become tough and dry on the size of the neck and cut off both claw arms the.. Lobster lengthwise.. place the lobsters on the grill, shell sides down sauce vierge adjust! A bright red orange shell, then the stovetop method is the way to go across! Find the cross that is located on the center of 4 plates your lobster. Fire in a charcoal or gas grill bib in a pinch best way to go space. Stovetop method is the way to kill a lobster that’s out of its head saute vegetables! Prepare grill ; heat should be opaque ) … Bring the water need to make it happen into! Claws with the butter begins to melt, baste with a brush all over the hottest of! You need to make it happen until lightly charred, 1 to 2 minutes side. 4 inches from fire center of 4 plates baste again with seasoned butter or oil! Recipe you need to make it happen, place the grilled lobsters on the grill, shell sides.. You want to reheat boiled lobster is good, but they take up a of...