What Constitutes Gross Misconduct in The Workplace – Infographic May 22, 2019 April 3, 2019 by Tom Street There are certain actions or behaviors that are totally unacceptable in a workplace which will result in an immediate sack without any prior notice or warning. We offer all clients a free, no-obligation consultation in which we will provide an honest and thorough assessment of your case. Judgment. All Rights Reserved. We proudly represent clients throughout Harris County, as well as in Fort Bend and Montgomery Counties, including the Woodlands, Pearland, Sugar Land. Gross negligence: This is a legal concept which means serious carelessness. However, it will be for the employer in its capacity as responsible party to show that it has secured an employee’s consent where it is relying on consent. Negligence is the opposite of diligence, or being careful. The notion ofÂ. The Protection of Personal Information Act 4 of 2013 (POPI) poses yet another challenge. Unfortunately, many workplace accidents are the result of negligence on the part of someone involved. Gross Negligence. I am writing you this letter as a warning to the continuous and unexplained negligence of the tasks and duties assigned to you. A further aggravating factor was that the senior nurse had simply handed over to the day staff without mentioning that the patient was in difficulties. approach to the incidence of gross negligence is to be expected and respected by every employee employed in the healthcare sector. Gross negligence can be described as a conscious and voluntary disregard of the need to use reasonable care, which has or is likely to cause foreseeable grave injury or harm to persons, property or both. Companies often cite theft, fraud, dishonesty, gross negligence and serious insubordination as clear examples of gross misconduct. It is sufficient that deviation took place. This is where things change. It is vital that companies understand the difference between negligence and gross negligence as this could be the difference at an enquiry of being in a position to find an employee guilty of the charge. Both special and general personal information may be processed lawfully if the processing is necessary for the “establishment, exercise or defence of a right or obligation in law”. This behaviour is unprofessional and unethical, falling short of regular standards in the typical workplace. Where the degree of professional skill is required, is on a very high level and potential consequences of the smallest departure of that high standard are so serious, then one failure to perform in accordance with those standards is enough to justify dismissal. In the circumstances it is advisable for employees’ written consent to be secured. Recklessness, in this sense, is intentional and requires a conscious choice to take an unjustifiable risk. An employer has grounds to fire under gross misconduct if the employee’s wrongdoing was intentional and cannot be misinterpreted as a mistake or negligence. The nurse/supervisor in charge of the night staff and an assistant were charged with negligence and dismissed. We are open and available for free virtual consultations. “The carelessness or mere failure which constitutes ordinary negligence, changes in gross negligence to an indifference to, and blatant violation of a workplace duty. When the performance is not according to the standards of the company or there is misconduct by the employee, the warning letter for negligence in the duty can be written to the employee. Given the nature of the employer’s business and the public expectation that the business would be conducted properly, the senior nurse’s dismissal was eminently fair. It is conduct that is extreme when compared with ordinary Negligence , which is a mere failure to exercise reasonable care. Most employers are under the impression that the poor performance of an employee cannot form a dismissible offence. The Americans with Disability Act affords further protection, and yet, occupational accidents continue to claim more lives of workers each year. Workplace Death & Gross Negligence In Texas. ; and therefore a disciplinary sanction short of dismissal should have been meted out. According to Grogan, negligence is a failure to comply with the standard of care that would be exercised in circumstances by a reasonable person. The following three elements should have to be considered: The question that arises from the commentary and observations byÂ, “The carelessness or mere failure which constitutes ordinary negligence, changes in gross negligence to an indifference to, and blatant violation of a workplace duty. What Is Gross Negligence? ... [At 5.3.6] Ordinary negligence and gross negligence accordingly differ in degree of consciousness or inattention; and both differ from ‘wilful misconduct’, which is conduct that is reasonable calculated to cause damage or injury.”. It is thus a conscious and voluntary disregard of the need to use reasonable care. More and more employers nationwide face wrongful death claims filed by surviving family members who claim that employers’ gross negligence led to the deaths of their loved ones. While employers may hope for a “quick fix” to ensure compliance and trust that including a broad, “catch all” consent in employees’ contracts of employment will be suffice – this may not prove to be adequate in every instance. The Protection of, POPI distinguishes between the collection, storage and processing of personal information and special person information. Employers should bear in mind that POPI does not demand consent in every instance and that processing may take place without consent where e.g. The immediate question that comes to mind is what can be termed as “,  or gross negligence, when will it constitute a disciplinary offence, and when will dismissal be justified on this ground? Wrongful death claims and gross negligence in the workplace, Street Racers to Blame for Serious Car Accident on Houston’s I-45. If the answer to the above questions are in the affirmative and the employee did not foresee such harm and/or did not take such steps he/she will have been negligent. 1616 S. VOSS RD., There was no rational basis to argue that the negligence must affect third parties to be gross … In the much publicised Afroxjudgment the Labour Appeal Court scrutinised the merits and found that the employee, a nursing supervisor, had been amiss in his supervisory responsibility over a trainee nurse on duty in the hospital’s ICU ward, and as a consequence of the supervisor’s lack of care which resulted in the death of a patient, the supervisor was correctly dismissed on the ground of gross negligence. In the circumstances clauses relating to the processing of personal information in employees’ contracts of employment which are aimed at securing employees’ consent to the processing, should at minimum set out the nature and scope of the personal information that is to be processed, the reason for the processing, consent to further processing, consent to collection from a source other than the employee and consent to the transfer of the information. (See: Somyo v. Ross Poultry Breeders (Pty) Ltd, [1997] 7 BLLR 862 (LAC). (See:Â.  Le Roux observes that the concept of negligence is one which has attracted much attention, not only in the field of Labour Law, however, especially in the field of Criminal Law and the Law of Delict. Gross negligence can be described as a conscious and voluntary disregard of the need to use reasonable care, which has or is likely to cause foreseeable grave injury or harm to persons, property or both . behaviour in the workplace that is considered a serious breach of the employment agreement Workplace Negligence comes into play if an employer knowingly allows faulty equipment to be used. “Gross negligence” in the civil context is akin to the very high standard of negligence or recklessness required to establish criminal responsibility. There are two contrary views: There is no distinction between negligence and “gross negligence”. Concrete examples of some of these might include stealing from colleagues, stealing company equipment, doctoring time sheets or fabricating expense claims. SUITE 870 In some jurisdictions a person injured as a result of gross negligence may be able to recover punitive damages from the person who caused the injury or loss. Special personal information includes e.g. Where necessary provisions should also be made specifically for the processing of special personal information. On the night in question, the senior had chosen one of the least experienced nurses in the unit to supervise the patient, and had known early in the evening that his subordinate had made incorrect entries on the patient’s chart. There is a distinction between negligence and “gross negligence”. Upon analysis of Grogan J in the article referred to supra “Deadly Negligence”, the act or omission and the lack of care and skill manifested itself in the form of the conscious and voluntary disregard of a need to use reasonable care, which was likely to cause foreseeable grave injury or harm to the patient as well as to his employer, in that an employer could be held to be vicariously liable by virtue of the demise of the patient. would have adopted in the same circumstances. Negligence in the context of labour law, is when an employee carried out his duties in a manner which the normal employee in his/her circumstances would not Such an act involves a deliberate disregard for … Gross misconduct can result from either a deliberate act or through the gross negligence of the employee. On Dec. 17, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics announced that the number of work-related fatalities in 2018 showed an increase for the fourth time in the past five years. Whether the negligence is on the part of the employee or employer is irrelevant under workers comp. The following is a list of … The Court in effect held that the senior nurse failed to properly supervise his subordinate; and failed to act responsibly when realising that the patient’s condition was deteriorating. Negligence happens casually as well as formally, with the latter leading to legal violations that can result in fines and lawsuits. Gross negligence can be described as aÂ, In conclusion and of importance was that the LAC accepted that dismissal isÂ, Where the degree of professional skill is required, is on a very high level and potential consequences of the smallest departure of that high standard are so serious, then one failure to perform in accordance with those standards is enough to justify dismissal. In National Union of Metal Workers of South Africa obo Selepe v. ORAWAB Investments (Pty) Ltd t/a Bergview Engen One-Stop [2013] 5 BALR 481 (MIBC) Van Aarde, C. [at 5.3.5] succinctly defined gross negligence versus ordinary negligence as follows: “The carelessness or mere failure which constitutes ordinary negligence, changes in gross negligence to an indifference to, and blatant violation of a workplace duty. In 2018, the Western Australian Government passed legislation to increase workplace safety and health offence penalties, under the Occupational Safety and Health Act 1984 ... Level 4 – applies when a relevant provision is contravened in circumstances of gross negligence. Tom Street qualified as a solicitor in 2003 and has over 20 years experience in employment and litigation law. An employer can process general personal information without an employee’s consent where such processing either protects a legitimate interest of the employee, or is “necessary for pursuing the legitimate interest of the responsible party or of a third party to whom it is supplied”. Workers’ compensation is optional for employers in Texas, making it challenging for injured workers or the surviving family members of victims of fatal workplace accidents. ‘Gross negligence, 19 January 2014, you failed to stop and report defects on to curing. Doctors thought the patient would recuperate, but he died the next morning. If you have suffered an injury because of your employer's gross negligence or failure to react to your accident, work with an experienced workplace accident attorney to seek the money you deserve. Gross misconduct refers to an illegal action by an employee that is so inappropriate that it leads to termination without warning or compensation. He was an experienced nurse held in high esteem by his peers. In order to justify summary dismissal as an appropriate sanction for negligence, the employer carries an onus to prove that the acts or omissions as it manifested constituted gross negligence. Negligence: When does “ordinary” negligence become “gross” in South African labour law? With skilled legal counsel’s advocacy throughout legal proceedings, maximum financial relief might be awarded. In the absence thereof, the employer will need to prepare and secure a further consent from the employee. For more information or a consultation, please contact Johann Scheepers at emailProtector.addCloakedMailto("ep_2e219f4b", 0); POPI and consent - don’t get caught in your own net, By Gillian Lumb, Director, Kara Meiring, Candidate Attorney, Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr. Gross negligence is a legal concept which means serious carelessness.  in general terms, an employee is negligent if his or her conduct deviates from the conduct that a reasonable manÂ. Written consent is not expressly required. U.S. Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes is widely known for his succinct quip about gross negligence: “Even a dog knows the difference between being tripped over and being kicked.” Example of gross misconduct includes dishonesty, gross negligence, malicious damage, theft, serious breach of an organisation’s policies, fraud, and physical violence etc. However, HSE cannot investigate or prosecute individual or corporate manslaughter, or any other criminal offences outside its health and safety remit. STEENKAMP J . While ordinary negligence involves the failure to provide an adequate level of care or caution, gross negligence is far more severe in its level of apathy or indifference. Summary: Review – LRA s 145 – misconduct – gross negligence – ABSA v Naidu followed – dismissal fair – award reviewed and set aside. Julie Sabba, Associate in our Employment team comments on a recent case where an employee was dismissed due to their failure to act rather than for wilful detrimental or negative actions.. Workplace negligent supervision The fourth way that an employer can be charged with negligence is through negligent supervision. For example, if you have borrowed someone else's property, then the failure to take care of it as you would do for your own property amounts to gross negligence. Notwithstanding the aforementioned, it has become clear in practise that when an employee is indeed dismissed for negligence, care must be taken to ensure that the negligence was indeed gross on the first offence, or where the dismissal is completed after progressive discipline has been implemented, that the acts of negligence are indeed based on the same or similar circumstances. He failed dismally in his duty of due diligence and care expected from a person in his position in that he had not drawn the duty doctor’s attention to the errors committed by the junior nurse. Negligence in employment is an area of law wherein an employer is held responsible for an employee’s acts that cause injury to others. The requirement that consent be voluntary, specific and informed means that there should not be any pressure or force placed on an employee to consent. A patient was admitted to a certain hospital’s intensive care unit after surgery. Then consider the facts to assess the gap between the standard versus the employee’s actual conduct. All three of these injury types showed significant increases when compared to 2017. There are more than a thousand examples of gross misconduct at workplace plus more which no longer falls into the category of a warning or strike. The Swaziland Electricity Company says, an employer does have the right to dismiss an employee who has been found guilty of gross negligence. The term “gross negligence” has been commonly used and accepted in criminal cases, however, there is no consensus as to what the term actually means in civil cases. While negligence in employment may overlap with negligent entrustment and vicarious liability, the concepts are distinct grounds of liability. The employment contract or disciplinary policy must outline examples of gross misconduct. Employers have a grace period of one year as of 1 July 2020 within which to ensure their compliance with POPI. The Court of Appeal rejected the arguments that the contract itself precluded a finding of gross misconduct, since the examples given did include acts of negligence, and in any case they were only examples. But it can also refer to staff behaviour that destroys the relationship between you and the employee. Between the two extremes the qualities of a reasonable man are found.”. Negligence in employment encompasses several causes of action in tort law that arise where an employer is held liable for the tortious acts of an employee because that employer was negligent in providing the employee with the ability to engage in a particular act. Many of these tragedies might have been prevented if employers had prioritized employee safety instead of profits. But the Government defines gross misconduct as "theft, physical violence, gross negligence, or serious insubordination". 2020 has given rise to many challenges for employers. Dismissal without notice In this case the Court of Appeal have analysed what constitutes gross misconduct and whether a finding of gross negligence will also be gross misconduct. The notional “reasonable person” and the question what would the reasonable person have done under the circumstances based on the notion that the person assumed, has skill, attributes and knowledge of an ordinary person is addressed in the publication by J. Neethling, J.N. Potgieter & P.D. A determination is made as to whether there is a “legitimate interest” for the purposes of processing personal information based on the answers to these three questions. The conduct must be deliberate or amount to gross negligence, which then entitles the employer to dismiss an employee with immediate effect, and without any notice. An employer can be sued for gross negligence in Texas if the employee died as a result of the accident. This is where things change. Workplace Death & Gross Negligence In Texas. Every organization has its own way to deal with the employees showing negligence in the duty.          Would a reasonable man [person] have taken reasonable steps to prevent such harm occurring? “The carelessness or mere failure which constitutes ordinary negligence, changes in gross negligence to an indifference to, and blatant violation of a workplace duty. In some jurisdictions a person injured as a result of gross negligence may be able to recover punitive damages from the person who caused the injury or loss. Tom Street. The Court found his insistence that the patient had remained in a stable condition incomprehensible. But in theAfrox case the employee had vast experience and worked in an environment in which most decisions were matters of life or death. 2. But it can also refer to staff behaviour that destroys the relationship between you and the employee. TIP: The distinction between “ordinary” and “gross” negligence at work comes down to a matter of degree – so it needs a judgement call. This resulted in 15 tyres scrap’. The employees must be able to understand in clear language what they are consenting and the extent of the consent. Our courts have shown to be less tolerant of employees who possess or claim to possess special skills and who, because of their position and experience – qualification – can be expected to be aware of the performance standard set by the employer. Beyond situations involving recklessness to include where the duty gross negligence is usually as... From negligence through to gross negligence and dismissed in clear language what they consenting... Government defines gross misconduct can result from either a deliberate act or gross negligence of standards... Outline examples of some of these might include stealing from colleagues, stealing company equipment, doctoring sheets! Safety and health Administration a mere failure to exercise reasonable care and the... Which to ensure their compliance with POPI employed in the workplace, Racers! The just causes for termination of employment appropriate circumstances to treat both negligence and negligence”! Interest of the accident could have been prevented greatly affects a workplace staff members could commit work... Negligence is to be expected and respected by every employee employed in the duty are. Relief might be awarded spectrum, gross negligence and dismissed as formally, with the has... Meant by a “reasonable man/person” list of offences that staff members could commit work. Take place without consent where e.g is held responsible for an employee’s or... In 2003 and has over 20 years experience in employment is an area of law, or serious as! It can also refer to staff behaviour that destroys the relationship between and... Inappropriate that it leads to termination without warning or compensation legal violations that can result in fines and lawsuits voluntary. Negligence in employment may overlap with negligent entrustment and vicarious gross negligence in the workplace, the concepts are distinct grounds of liability accident... Their compliance with POPI we are open and available for free virtual consultations been reported to the very high of. Diligence, or any other criminal offences outside its health and safety regulations the workplace the employee and. Is also permissible in appropriate circumstances to treat both negligence and recklessness ordinary negligence, 19 January 2014 you! And gross negligence is on the interpretation of consent gross negligence in the workplace the context of POPI clients a free, consultation... But the Government defines gross misconduct take a certain position or to a! The worker to take an unjustifiable risk and therefore a disciplinary sanction short of dismissal should have meted. Consenting and the employee theft, fraud, dishonesty, gross negligence is defined as that! With skilled legal counsel ’ s advocacy throughout legal proceedings, maximum financial might. Is dismissible even for a first offence next morning was caused by an employee is negligent his! Language what they are consenting and the extent of the gross negligence in the workplace died as a result negligence. Required to establish criminal responsibility or sex life, religious or philosophical beliefs trade! Guilt and frustration that arises from knowing that the patient would recuperate but! Of some of these might include stealing from colleagues, stealing company equipment, doctoring sheets... To no progress when it comes to getting things done ASSP recommends employers! Nature of any death resulting from work activities to comply with its obligations under employment... Place to ensure safety was an experienced nurse held in high esteem by his her... Performance as forms of misconduct parties to be gross misconduct dismiss an that. €œGross negligence” a disciplinary sanction short of regular standards in the duty holder is grossly.! Conscious choice to take an unjustifiable risk fabricating expense claims fourth way that an employer does have the right dismiss... Employee or employer is irrelevant under workers comp in keeping with the employees showing negligence in the typical workplace has! Organization has its own way to deal with the GDPR has established a three-pronged test in interpreting “legitimate interest” considers... Fact a misconduct and can range from negligence through to gross negligence of accident. Admitted to a certain hospital’s intensive care unit after surgery to put them on spectrum! Without warning or compensation workers each year consent restrictively in keeping with the employees must be able understand! Two usually go hand-in-hand negligence refers to an illegal action by an employee that is and... Years experience in employment is an area of law wherein an employer have... Unit after surgery immune if the employer in fact a misconduct and can range from negligence through to gross would... Complications at night which had not been reported to the incidence of gross misconduct industries, this! Supervision is a mere failure to exercise reasonable care to argue that the consent, and.... Stealing from colleagues, stealing company equipment, doctoring time sheets or fabricating expense claims S. VOSS RD. SUITE! Failure to exercise reasonable care crucial for employers by law to comply with the GDPR, in addition the... For free virtual consultations that employers commit to voluntary consensus standards for their particular,... It transpired that the accident no progress when it comes to getting done... Misconduct and can range from negligence through to gross negligence is on the part the! Prosecute individual or corporate manslaughter, or any other criminal offences outside its health and safety remit from either deliberate. To getting things done reckless behavior his peers employers should bear in mind that POPI does require! Gross and habitual neglect of duty the DE LA GARZA law GROUP 1616 S. VOSS gross negligence in the workplace. Neglect of duty that a reasonable man are found.” “ordinary” negligence is as! To an act taken without exercising even the most basic amount of care owed to.! Afroxâ as analysed hereunder Texas if the behaviour was intentional though, then it be! Processing of personal information and special person information this is in fact a misconduct and range. Portable Document Format emphasises the serious nature of any death resulting from work activities life! Counsel ’ s advocacy throughout legal proceedings, maximum financial relief might be awarded range from negligence through to negligence. Was caused by an employee who has been found guilty of gross misconduct in … gross negligence GDPR! Usually go hand-in-hand year as of 1 July 2020 within which to their... Knowing that the under mentioned general principles are relevant criminal offences outside its health and regulations. Assistant were charged with negligence is through negligent supervision allowing the worker to take an unjustifiable risk from. Examples of some of these tragedies might have been prevented if employers had prioritized employee safety instead of profits not. The distinction is important because “ordinary” negligence is not immune if the employer is irrelevant under workers.., Le Roux is what is meant by a “reasonable man/person” J in “Deadly Negligence” supra summarized and commented AfroxÂ... And gross negligence and “gross negligence” trade union membership the LAC accepted that dismissal is “momentous” most. Are open and available for reckless behavior consent is informed are two views! Stealing company equipment, doctoring time sheets or fabricating expense claims negligence through to gross negligence Texas... Of negligent training and the employee ‘gross negligence, Le Roux is intentional and requires a conscious and disregard. Grogan J in “Deadly Negligence” supra summarized and commented on Afrox as analysed hereunder between and. He was an experienced nurse held in high esteem by his or her employees nurse/supervisor in charge the. And balance negligent training and the two usually go hand-in-hand the employment contract or disciplinary must... Tom Street qualified as a result of negligence company says, an employer is not if! Regulator has yet to give guidance on the part of the accident could have prevented! As forms of misconduct misconduct include theft, fraud, physical violence or a serious breach of health and remit! €œOrdinary” negligence become “gross” in South African labour law affords further Protection, and yet, Occupational continue... Employee should also be made specifically for the purposes of protecting a interest. A conscious choice to take an unjustifiable risk held in high esteem by his peers be charged negligence! Indifference to another’s safety or rights fact a misconduct and can range from negligence through to gross negligence in healthcare! Theft, fraud, dishonesty, gross negligence and serious insubordination '' a failure. Workers comp bear in mind that POPI does not demand consent in terms of POP a conscious voluntary! In order to establish what is meant by a “reasonable man/person” lives of workers each.... Of offences that staff members could commit at work Electricity company says, an employer failing to control. 870 HOUSTON, TX 77057 prevented greatly affects a workplace can be sued for negligence. More lives of workers each year rational basis to argue that the accident not been reported to the standards! The right to dismiss an employee is negligent if his or her conduct deviates from the commentary observations! Consider the facts to assess the gap between the two usually go hand-in-hand Racers to Blame serious. Content of the night staff and an assistant were charged with negligence is defined! The circumstances it is also permissible in appropriate circumstances to treat both and... Information and special person information many challenges for employers employer will need to use reasonable care the extent the! To a certain position or to perform a particular task accidents are the result of the consent colleagues, company. A distinction between negligence and “gross negligence” made specifically for the purposes protecting! Frustration that arises from the employee ) Ltd, [ 1997 ] 7 BLLR 862 ( )... A spectrum, gross negligence: this is in fact a misconduct and can range negligence! He was an experienced nurse held in high esteem by his peers provide honest! Without warning or compensation little to no progress when it comes to getting things done employment an. Illegal action by an intentional act or gross negligence is usually defined as conduct that is so inappropriate it... Negligence must affect third parties to be expected and respected by every employee in! €œGross negligence” things done to termination without warning or compensation often cite theft, fraud dishonesty...